We should stand with and applaud the Stz’uminus First Nation

Re: Michael Smith's letter about denial of aboriginal title and rights.


Denial of aboriginal title and rights, as Michael Smith advocates in his recent letter to the editor, rests on foundation of racism and intolerance that leaves no room for reconciliation of un-extinguished indigenous land rights and the exercise of indigenous self-determination. Dubiously declaring oneself not a racist does not excuse a position that perpetuates inequality and injustice in our community.

As I teach my undergraduate students at UVic, this tired tirade is familiar from public debates of 25 years ago, inflamed by ideologues like Tom Flanagan, and taken up by Canadians who remain fundamentally ignorant of the ongoing legacies of our colonial history.  Now widely recognized as morally reprehensible and based on a deeply flawed understanding of basic principles in Canadian common law, such arguments should be water long under the bridge.  However the voices of trolls living under those bridges still pop up, as we have read here and in similarly abhorrent letters published by the Nanaimo Daily News last year.

What letters like these do, however, is raise the possibility of conversation about the recognition of aboriginal title and rights, hopefully offering a departure point for genuine dialogue between neighbours -— aboriginal and settler -— who are all here to stay. Smith himself says that the “first order of business is to affirm just what are the public lands and waterways.”

The Stz’uminus First Nation has unextinguished aboriginal title and rights throughout their territories. No historic treaty was ever signed here; therefore the substantial legal consequence of indigenous property, usufructuary and governance rights continues to be in full force and effect throughout the “public lands and waterways” in Stz’uminus territories today.  This fact cannot be wished away however inconvenient some may find it.

Indeed, the Crown’s duty to consult and accommodate Stz’uminus First Nation on matters that impact their fishing rights was affirmed by the BC Court of Appeal back in the mid-1990s. While Stz’uminus has tried over the past 20 years to negotiate recognition and respect for these rights both in and out of the BC Treaty Process, substantive agreement has been elusive. The Crown’s legacy of denial continues to be felt in the current dispute over the impact of commercial and recreational fisheries on the exercise of Stz’uminus title and rights.

As neighbours and friends, we should stand with the Stz’uminus First Nation, insisting that governments engage respectfully and with honour. We should applaud Stz’uminus First Nation’s remarkable recent achievement in negotiating out of a full one-third of the oppressive Indian Act.  We should congratulate Stz’uminus First Nation in the success they have had in envisioning and launching their new school facilities (and perhaps ask ourselves how it could be that SD68 served them so poorly that they needed to take their children away).  We should continue working together to develop our mutual future economy and community. And most importantly, we should appreciate and acknowledge that the Ladysmith community has the honour and privilege to be located in the territory of Stz’uminus First Nation.

When the editors of the Nanaimo Daily News published not one, but two, letters with the same repugnant tone as Smith’s feature letter in the Chronicle and Take 5 they were met with protests, and formal complaints to the BC Press Council.  Community leaders in Nanaimo immediately responded,  taking concrete measures to educate and inform, and to foster genuine conversation to take the place of specious sentiments founded in unchallenged ignorance. I hope our Ladysmith community takes the opportunity to have such a meaningful dialogue.

Brian Thom




Just Posted

Pedestrian struck by vehicle in Stz’uminus dies from injuries

A male pedestrian was struck in the early morning of June 25

Bitcoin and cryptocurrency scams targeting the most vulnerable

Safely navigating a new type of gold rush frontier

Ladysmith soccer player brings home B.C. Premier League championship

This is the third consecutive cup for the U16 Vancouver Island Wave, and the second for Gueldenstern

Community groups make a large amount of money available to Chemainus grads

Scholarships and bursaries for class members for post-secondary total $85,000

Chemainus Secondary grads embark on a new journey

Friday ceremony a time to reflect on the past, look forward to the future

Astronaut David Saint-Jacques returns to Earth, sets Canadian space record

Native of Saint-Lambert, Que., set a record for longest single spaceflight by a Canadian at 204 days

Thieves steal two $40K chairs featuring gold serpents from Vancouver furniture store

Chairs believed to be the only two of its kind in Canada, police said

Poll: Rising gas prices force B.C. residents rethink summer road trips

63 per cent of respondents reported gas prices are impacting their day-to-day finances

PHOTO: Moose cow and calf relax in Williams Lake flower garden

The homeowners got a surprise when they checked their most recent surveillance footage

Two in hospital after plane crashes in Okanagan Lake

RCMP say wheels left down caused landing plane to overturn on lake

The world’s Indigenous speakers gather in B.C.’s capital to revitalize languages

Organizers estimate about 1,000 delegates from 20 countries will be at the conference

Join talks on international treaty: B.C. First Nations mark ‘historic moment’

Representatives of the Ktunaxa, Syilx/Okanagan and Secwepemc Nations participated

Companies need clearer rules on workplace relationships, study suggests

One-third of Canadians have been in love at work, and half say no policy on the matter exists

Foot ferry service in Nanaimo won’t happen this summer

Island Ferries says it still needs to secure funding

Most Read